Abstract Early musicologists embraced evolutionary thinking in their understanding of historical change. In the last century, however, research on music history has fragmented along methodological and institutional lines—humanities scholars produce rich descriptions of specific examples, including all relevant details and context, while scientists use empiricism to identify the processes driving general trends. The authors think that the emerging field of cultural evolution has the potential to bridge this gap. In this chapter, they summarize recent research on the cultural evolution of music, focusing on studies of musical content and context, as well as novel methodologies. Then, they address five open questions and key challenges for interdisciplinary research on music history: overcoming epistemological differences, addressing biased historical preservation, understanding globalization and technology, disentangling evolution and progress, and identifying the drivers of innovation. By addressing these challenges, they aim to foster a more interdisciplinary and collaborative approach to musical history and evolution.